The Staircase Episode 4 Recap and Ending Explained

The Staircase Episode 4 Recap and Ending Explained1

The Staircase Episode 4 Recap ‘Common Sense’ and Ending Explained – Sophie speaks about Michael in 2017 as trial footage plays back. And things aren’t looking good for Michael throughout the trial. The jury learns from an expert how the blood splatters can only signify one thing: murder throughout the trial. Clayton becomes agitated while watching the trial on TV and decides to pay a visit to his family.

Common Sense,’ the fourth episode of HBO Max’s crime series ‘The Staircase,’ is about Michael Peterson’s trial. As the trial nears its conclusion, the prosecution and defence question many key witnesses. For his documentary, Jean-Xavier interviews an unexpected person regarding Michael. Clayton, despite Todd’s reluctance, persists on remaining with his father and discovers crucial evidence in Kathleen’s murder case.

Meanwhile, Michael’s history haunts him when a close friend of Elizabeth testifies against him. The episode comes to a stunning conclusion that has a significant impact on Michael’s life. Here is our opinion on the situation!

Must Read: Is Michael Peterson Gay or Bisexual in Real-Life?

The Staircase Episode 4 Recap

The Staircase Episode 4 ‘Common Sense’ Recap

‘Common Sense’ starts with Sophie interrogating Jean-Xavier about Michael. The prosecution continues to emphasise Michael’s bisexuality, which the defence finds worrisome. Kathleen’s autopsyist, Dr. Deborah Radisch, testified that she was most likely murdered.

After submitting multiple autopsy files of people who had been beaten by death, Rudolf claims that it is practically impossible to die without cracking the skull or harming the brain, which Kathleen did not. Agnes, Martha and Margaret’s babysitter, testifies against Michael regarding Elizabeth Ratliff’s death while the Ratliff family is in Germany with the Petersons.

To refute the notion of blood spatter expert Duane Deaver, who testified that the blood marks on the crime scene suggest murder, Rudolf introduces Henry Lee, the private analyst he and Michael hired. Clayton returns to Durham to see his father. Clayton discovers the blow poke that was used in their house while tinkering on a car in the garage.

He dials Michael’s number, and Michael informs Rudolf that the “suspected murder weapon” is in his garage. The attorney exhibits the poke to the jury, emphasising the lack of blood and other suspicious markings in the material to suggest that his client did not murder his wife.

The Staircase Episode 4 Ending Explained

The Staircase Episode 4 Ending Explained

Michael is found guilty of Kathleen’s murder by the jury. Despite Rudolf’s success in disproving the prosecution’s argument that Kathleen was killed by Michael, most likely with the blow poke, Freda contradicts the material’s presentation by emphasising Michael’s bisexuality and extramarital affairs once more.

The prosecution relies on portraying Michael as an immoral being capable of murder rather than finding the murder weapon or presenting conclusive evidence or testimony. When Kathleen’s sister Candace says that Michael and Kathleen’s marriage is failing, the theory gathers traction.

The jury’s decision appears to be influenced by Michael’s bisexuality, extramarital affairs, and the death of Elizabeth. Despite the errors of the prosecution’s hypotheses, witness testimony, and evidence, they eventually think Michael killed Kathleen after she learned of his bisexuality.

The prosecution’s claim that such a revelation sparked a quarrel between the pair, culminating in Michael’s murder of Kathleen, becomes the jury’s conviction. Michael and Rudolf listen to the judgement – the former is given a life sentence with no chance of release.

The prosecution and defence both fail to establish their theories in front of the jury from the beginning of the trial. Michael’s trial is further complicated by the inaccuracy of evidence and testimony, as well as the plethora of “possibilities.”

However, Michael’s sexual orientation, Jim and Freda’s not-so-surprising trump card, gets in the way of Rudolf’s hopes of getting a favourable decision for his client. Despite this, the prosecution wins the case without demonstrating Michael’s guilt or locating a murder weapon.

Recommended: Did Michael Peterson and Sophie Brunet Date in Real? Are Both Still Together?

What is Sophie’s Relationship with Michael

What is Sophie and Michael’s Relationship like?

Sophie is the editor of Jean-documentary Xavier’s on Michael and his trial. Jean sends the tape to Sophie in France to begin editing after shooting a substantial amount. She begins to watch and listen to Michael for hours on end through the footage.

Sophie believes the man in front of her on the television isn’t a killer because of the time and energy she spends with him. She writes Michael in prison a lengthy letter stating her confidence that he did not murder his wife. Sophie’s letter to Michael leads to her becoming his partner.

Sophie becomes a big presence in Michael’s life, as shown in the show’s opening moments. Sophie’s devotion and warmth for him make it clear that they are much more than two acquaintances or even friends, despite the fact that the nature of their relationship has yet to be revealed.

Sophie’s unclear relationship with Michael is based on her belief that she has seen and listened to him long enough or longer than anybody else, for that matter, to trust in his claim of innocence.

What did you think of season 1 episode 4 of HBO’s Max series The Staircase (2022)? Leave a comment below.

With an HBO Max subscription, you can watch this series.