ID’s ‘Who the (Bleep) Did I Marry?’ 3×02 One Night Affair: Beth Williams Murder

Beth Williams Murder – Let’s begin our exploration with the Investigation Discovery’s series “Who the (Bleep) Did I Marry?” Season 3 episode 2 “One Night Affair.” This episode explores the tragic demise of Beth Williams in Baker City, Oregon, in March 1986, leaving local authorities baffled by what seemed like an unusual crime scene. However, an anonymous tip and statements from several witnesses provided essential leads that led the police directly to the suspect. The purpose of this episode is to offer a meticulous, chronological account of events leading up to, during, and following this horrendous act. Rest assured; we have all pertinent details regarding this incident, such as the identity and location of the perpetrator. So let’s embark on this exciting journey together!

Beth Williams Murder Story

Beth Williams held both editor and advertising manager positions at the Boardman Enterprise in Baker City, Oregon, in 1986. After working at the paper for almost one and a half years, Beth decided to visit her family but did not return home on March 22. This prompted her mother, Ellen, to file a missing person report. Beth was last seen at Cattle Kates saloon, but authorities made a grim discovery eleven miles south on Trail Creek Road: her body in a shallow grave.

Five days after Beth’s disappearance, on March 27, her body and purse were discovered scattered in different locations nearby. Law enforcement found a shovel approximately half a mile away. The coroner’s examination revealed that she had experienced severe head trauma before succumbing to brutal bludgeoning. Further investigation led them to uncover a nearby rock that may have been used in her murder. Several individuals even claimed they saw Beth leave a bar accompanied by someone on the night of March 24 when she disappeared.

Beth Williams’ tragic demise is a chilling reminder of the risks lurking behind seemingly routine situations. As we delve deeper into her story, we will unearth more details regarding the suspect and gain more insights into who or what might have caused it. Join us as we piece together the puzzle that surrounds this tragic case!

Investigation and Arrest

In 1980, Robin Faulk was a 19-year-old farm girl in Oregon when she found herself pregnant and abandoned by her high school sweetheart, who also happened to be the biological father of her child. Feeling isolated and uncertain about the path ahead, Robin returned home to Richland Farms near Baker County to give her daughter the best life possible, working alongside her father.

At this point, Robin began dating Jerry Joe Wilson, an easygoing delivery man with attractive height, good looks, and an outdoor-oriented mindset. She found him attractive enough for her tastes, and he had an affinity for children, leaving Robin feeling butterflies when they first met. Jerry’s ability to bond with Robin’s daughter ultimately brought them closer together, leading to their marriage in December 1980. They officially adopted Robin’s daughter as part of the adoption process and then relocated from Richland back to Baker City shortly afterwards.

After moving into their Baker City home, Robin Wilson quickly adjusted to life with her new husband, Jerry Wilson, and their children. They also rented out a spare house nearby. However, she soon noticed a shift in Jerry’s behaviour. He was often absent from home during working hours, went out late with colleagues or friends, or did not return on weekends. At first, she understood his role as a provider since he earned enough income to cover basic expenses. But she soon realized something had changed about his behaviour. He became more distant at home.

Robin became suspicious of her mother-in-law when she started paying for groceries without owning a vehicle, raising suspicions. To her shock and surprise, Jerry revealed he had been unemployed for some time and relied heavily on his family for support. Yet he had never revealed any of this information to Robin, leaving her distressed.

As Jerry’s absences and behaviour became increasingly concerning, Robin took it upon herself to provide for their family by seeking employment. In the summer of 1984, she gave birth to their third child, a son. Yet Jerry continued with his old habits despite her attempts at support. She was distraught to witness firsthand evidence of infidelity between him and Robin. On March 21, 1986, she confronted Jerry and presented an ultimatum.

Unbeknownst to her, Jerry Wilson’s response was unexpectedly explosive. He shouted and punched the wall so hard that he shattered his hand. Fearful for her own safety, Robin took refuge in another room as Jerry quickly left without looking back. He didn’t return home that night either. Later, devastating news arrived about Beth Williams being taken. Upon hearing this report on the radio, Robin felt sick to her stomach, confirming the information about Beth Williams.

Eyewitness accounts provided detectives with vital clues into Beth’s murder. Eyewitnesses said they saw Jerry and Beth leaving Cattle Kates together at 2 am on March 22. On March 24, when Jerry returned home, the police arrived at Robin’s residence, confirming her worst fears. During the interview with authorities, Jerry offered to undergo a polygraph exam as evidence against himself. However, shortly before this examination was scheduled to take place, he suddenly stopped showing up for work at the Chevron oil distributor firm he owned.

The events unfolding so far reveal a tumultuous relationship and increasing suspicions surrounding Jerry’s involvement in Beth Williams’ case. As this captivating tale continues, further details will surface that shed light on what really lies behind these troubling circumstances. So stay tuned as we unravel its intricate mysteries!

Prosecution of Jerry Joe Wilson in Beth Williams’ Murder

Jerry Joe Wilson took a dramatic turn when he failed a polygraph exam on March 27, 2019. Subsequently, he was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. He confessed both to Beth and to the police of having committed the murder. Reports indicate that after leaving a pub together, Jerry and Beth went directly to Jerry’s cabin for a sexual encounter. However, Beth became upset when she realized Jerry hadn’t taken birth control as promised. According to Jerry, her anger persisted until he revealed to her that he had undergone a vasectomy. This revelation further angered Beth, leading to a physical altercation.

According to Jerry, Beth’s anger escalated quickly, prompting her to insult and physically attack him with multiple punches. Driven by these events, Jerry lost control and drove Beth to a remote area along Trail Creek Road, where an intense exchange occurred between them. This ultimately led him to strike her skull multiple times with a rock, resulting in her tragic demise.

As a result of these events, Jerry Joe Wilson pleaded guilty to first-degree murder at the end of June 1986 and received a sentence of 10-20 years to life imprisonment. After serving 14 years behind bars, he was granted parole from his life sentence.

The resolution of this case has brought closure while simultaneously raising questions about justice and the sentencing process. Incidents like this one leave an indelible imprint on the individuals involved and the communities at large, leaving a lasting impact long after the incidents have passed.

Must Read: ID’s ‘Matriarch of Murder?’ – Vera Jo Reigle Messersmith Murder

Exit mobile version