Brooks Jennings Murder – Investigation Discovery’s crime show Fear Thy Neighbor’s fourth episode of Season 8, titled “Unwelcome to the Neighborhood,” delves into an alarming incident that took place in West Goshen Township, Pennsylvania. The episode on Brooks Jennings’ murder sheds light on an explosive year-long conflict that ultimately led to his violent demise in August 2017. Law enforcement quickly apprehended a suspect at the crime scene, where they found him standing near Brooks’ lifeless body while holding the murder weapon. As part of our pursuit of justice, we aim to provide you with all the relevant details regarding the motives and identities of those responsible. It is vital to present the facts accurately for an account of events.
Brooks Jennings’ Murder Story
Since Carter moved into his wife’s elderly father’s care, tensions between him and his new neighbour, a 51-year-old named Jennings, have escalated rapidly. Their heated argument became so intense that the police needed to intervene multiple times – at one point, Carter even drove his car through Jennings’ front door during an argument about Carter’s daughter being treated differently. Law enforcement eventually detained Carter for questioning.
On August 8, 2017, near their Box Elder Drive home, Carter was found standing over Jennings with the murder weapon in hand, and his family witnessed this horrific event from within their house. Jill, Jennings’ widow, finds some solace in knowing her husband gave his life while protecting his loved ones and the community against Carter’s aggression. Carter claims self-defence, as he believes Jennings was about to attack him with a knife.
Steve Oliver, who knew Carter well, asserts that she was known for having an explosive temper. Oliver asserts that Carter, 51 years old at the time, has been harassing George Brooks Jennings and Jill since moving into their tranquil neighbourhood in Chester County a few years ago. Oliver claims Carter specifically targeted Jill Jennings for harassment. Oliver expressed his concerns regarding Carter’s conduct by declaring her behaviour a risk to society: “That individual poses a danger to society.”
Investigation and Arrest
Oliver estimates that Carter has called West Goshen police over 70 times during the past five years due to his ongoing dispute with Brooks Jennings and has filed an excessive number of reports. While West Goshen police acknowledge this, they do not have exact figures available for review. Prosecutors allege that Carter shot Brooks Jennings early Tuesday morning during an altercation that further escalated their ongoing feud in West Goshen and killed him with gunfire as soon as it escalated further.
Carter’s attorney asserts that her client acted in self-defence after being assaulted. On Wednesday afternoon, Jill Jennings, who witnessed Carter shooting her husband through an interior window, politely declined to speak with reporters, even when surrounded by family and friends. Oliver stood under a nearby tree where Brooks Jennings died and expressed compassion for them and his anger toward Carter’s actions.
Oliver believes the incident could have been avoided. After speaking with law enforcement personnel and witnesses, it became apparent to him that there was limited action police could take if someone behaved irrationally or aggressively on their own property. Chief Joseph Gleason from West Goshen Police Department stated they received a complaint from concerned neighbours regarding Carter’s possession of firearms on his property.
Oliver declared, “I understand both the law and common sense,” noting it was time for enough is enough. Chief Gleason maintained that his office had taken all possible steps to control the dispute. If possible, they would have taken further steps against Carter due to the allegations but lacking concrete proof. According to Gleason’s statements, seven encounters between Carter and the police occurred since January.
Carter called West Goshen police himself to report someone’s objections to his motorcycle’s revving, with their last encounter occurring shortly before 8 pm on Monday night, before Jennings was murdered. Police were summoned after another argument between Jennings and Carter, which Chief Gleason described as a verbal dispute. According to Chief Gleason’s description, it involved cursing and video recordings in Carter’s backyard. The District Attorney’s Office released a statement detailing this event, which also involved cursing.
As time passed, the situation escalated further. According to Carter’s lawsuit, around 1:00 a.m., after returning home from running errands and seeing Jennings outside, Carter went inside his house to retrieve his Ruger semiautomatic handgun before returning outside. He informed officers of an argument between Jennings and himself over Jennings shining a flashlight directly in his direction. Carter sparked it off by using flashlight beams directed at him, causing further tension between them.
According to the lawsuit, Carter activated his high beams and drove his car onto the grass near Jennings’ driveway, positioning it to face him directly. Carter stepped away from his vehicle during an argument that eventually resulted in Carter shooting him. Jennings fell unconscious, and Carter stood over him while still lying motionless in his driveway and fired another shot into his head before firing another shot into him.
Prosecution of Clayton Carter in the Brooks Jennings Murder
Carter maintains his innocence and strongly refutes the prosecution’s allegations brought forth by Thomas Ost-Prisco and Vincent Cocco. Carter goes as far as characterizing Jill Jennings as a liar and her late husband as an alcoholic. At 53 years old, he even said, to much amusement from Jill Jennings’ family, that Brooks was an attack against him. In his own words, he adds, “They owe my family an apology.”
Carter made similar claims of self-defenses when arrested for murdering Jennings in West Goshen two years ago. Authorities claimed he left his knife at the crime scene since Jennings did not have fingerprints on it. An argument between both men may have started when Jennings installed a security system with powerful spotlights that illuminated Carter’s driveway directly.
In June, a Chester County jury found Carter guilty of first-degree murder, possessing an instrument of crime, and tampering with evidence. Authorities believed Carter harbored fantasies of killing Jennings over a period of several months due to their increased tension. Jill Jennings addressed Carter directly during the incident: “You killed my husband. He would never intentionally harm you.” Carter is currently incarcerated at Eastern State Penitentiary.