Libby Caswell Death: Was She Murdered or Did She Commit Suicide?

Libby Caswell Death Was She Murdered or Did She Commit Suicide

Libby Caswell Death – Welcome to a perplexing tale that asks the unsettling question, Was it Murder or Suicide? This article examines the life and death of Libby Caswell, an unexpected twist in her life that caused controversy and doubt over its official conclusion. This piece highlights her untimely demise revealing all its mysterious circumstances as well as family efforts and experts’ investigations leading up to it and ultimately their relentless search for truth.

Libby Caswell’s tragic story has become the focus of much discussion on iHeart podcast ‘What Happened to Libby Caswell.’ Her life-altering event challenges the conventional narrative and leaves us perplexed as to its exact sequence of events on that fateful day, leaving many questioning if she was murdered or took her own life? Come explore details and evidence that remain mysterious about her demise!

Who was Libby Caswell

Who was Libby Caswell?

Before we delve deeper into the unfathomable circumstances surrounding Libby’s death, let us first get acquainted with her. Elizabeth “Libby” Caswell was an engaging individual who left an indelible mark on all those she encountered during her short yet tragically cut short 21-year lifespan.

Libby was a force of energy and enthusiasm. In high school, she made an impression as a cheerleader bursting with positivity and vitality; her interests extended to dance, gymnastics and modeling. Her zest for life shone through in everything she did – especially her deep affection for Alexavier, who she doted on with such love that others couldn’t help but be drawn by her infectious smile and laughter.

Libby was making progress despite life’s difficulties, determined to overcome any hurdles and create a better life for herself and her son. On December 11, 2017, though, her life abruptly took an unexpected and shocking turn that left everyone she cared for reeling with disbelief and shock.

Libby Caswell Death Story

Libby Caswell Death Story

That fateful day began early when Libby and Devon checked into the Sports Stadium Motel for an overnight stay, where alcohol and drugs would come to play an influential part.

Libby and Devon engaged in an intense argument regarding Devon’s drug and alcohol consumption, prompting a chaotic start to their day that would soon unfold with bizarre events that followed.

Devon’s account of the day becomes alarmingly ominous when Libby decides to take a shower around 11 a.m. He claims he fell asleep while waiting for her, eventually awakening around 8 p.m. with no trace of Libby anywhere in sight in their bedroom.

Devon discovered something alarming when he noticed a belt hanging outside of the bathroom door and opened it, only to be met by a horrifying scene: Libby lay unconscious on the floor with the belt still wrapped around her neck. Panic ensued as Devon desperately searched for any sign of life; in vain. Overcome by this gruesome sight, Devon left the motel immediately and called 911 for assistance.

Investigation of Libby Caswell Death Case

Investigation of Libby Caswell Death Case

Police presence added another layer of intrigue to the unfolding narrative. An eyewitness in an adjacent room reported hearing disturbing sounds – a male and female engaged in what seemed like a violent altercation; the witness reportedly listened to a plea from a female voice: “Please stop hurting me“. These events transpired about 20 minutes before police arrival.

Disarray in the motel room only added to its mysterious atmosphere; clothes, empty alcohol bottles and personal effects were scattered about, creating an appearance of disorder. Officers initially treated this case as potential strangulation or murder rather than suicide.

The disturbing discovery in the bathroom was unnerving: Libby’s lifeless body was discovered wedged between the toilet and bathtub with Devon’s camouflage belt tightly secured around her neck. Rigor mortis had set in, suggesting she had been dead for some time; to make matters more puzzling, blood was observed coming from Libby’s nose but investigators could not establish its source.

Scenes such as this raise several questions, with little evidence available to provide solid answers.

Was Libby Caswell Murdered, or Did She Commit Suicide

Was Libby Caswell Murdered, or Did She Commit Suicide?

At the core of this baffling case lies an enduring question: Was Libby Caswell murdered, or did she opt to end her own life? The investigation took an intricate path, featuring various accounts and pieces of evidence which both support and counter the idea that she committed suicide.

Devon was initially the center of attention due to his history of domestic abuse and substance use. When his account of events on that day, combined with his history, became public knowledge, it drew intense scrutiny. Devon claimed Libby had been struggling with depression and made suicidal threats and claimed he had been awake from 11 a.m. until 8 p.m. before falling asleep again for eight hours, during which time she reportedly died. Devon denied any role in her death adamantly.

However, Devon’s friend who was present at the scene, provided evidence contradicting this narrative. He supported Devon’s claims that Libby was suicidal and had consumed vodka that morning; yet toxicology reports indicated an absence of any alcohol in her system, casting doubt upon this version of events.

Eyewitness reports of hearing an unpleasant altercation next door only added more layers of confusion and suspicions of misconduct. Allegations by them about hearing a woman pleading with the violence to end further increased suspicions that something untoward had taken place.

Numerous individuals, including Libby’s caseworker, witnessed domestic violence within her relationship with Devon. One such incident included an eyewitness report of Devon trying to strangle Libby just days before her death.

The Caseworker of Libby, who was helping her regain custody of her son, testified that she had never heard Libby mention suicide or display any signs of self-harm. Instead, the caseworker described an optimistic version of Libby, who was determined to improve her life and ensure a secure environment for her child.

Domestic disturbance calls at Libby’s parents’ home indicated the degree of hostility between them, eventually culminating in their home being classified by authorities as a nuisance property and incurring fines from authorities.

Cindy sought justice and answers for her daughter Libby by turning to Alliance for HOPE International, an organization that specializes in domestic violence issues. Dr. Bill Smock of Alliance for HOPE’s Training Institute on Strangulation Prevention conducted a detailed investigation and came to a chilling conclusion based on his expertise and experience.

Dr. Smock provided evidence that cast doubt on Libby’s suicide theory, including marks found on her neck that did not line up with those typically associated with strangulation. Based on this expert opinion, Dr. Smock concluded that these marks did not line up with what is seen with strangulation victims.

Must Read: Patricia Newsom Murder: Who Killed Her? – A Cold Case Story