The death of Todd Joseph Stermer was a shock to his family and the whole community of Lawrence, Michigan. In January 2007, a fire destroyed Todd’s home, ending his life as a loving husband and father. At first, it looked like a terrible accident, but it quickly turned into a case full of doubt, proof of wrongdoing, and years of court battles. CBS’ 48 Hours episode, “The Death of Todd Stermer”, revisits the heartbreaking case and examines the shocking events that unfolded before and after his death. Here at Spiky TV, we’ll break down who Todd was, how he died, and the long legal journey that followed.
Who Was Todd Stermer?
Todd Joseph Stermer was born on November 22, 1964, in Kalamazoo, Michigan, to Hilmer D. and Sandra Burke Stermer. Todd grew up in a warm and loving family with four siblings: brothers Brad and Brock Duane and sisters Kathy and Kelly.
He went to Portage Northern High School and then Kalamazoo Valley Community College (KVCC). Todd was very talented. He loved coaching kids in sports like baseball, football, basketball, and softball. He also liked hunting and woodworking, and he was good enough at it to build his own house. He eventually started a business that sold gloves and hunting suits.
People who knew Todd said he was hard-working, kind, and loved his family. People in his community respected him because he was dedicated to both work and family.
Todd Stermer’s Family Life
Todd met Linda Kay in 1989. At the time, she was separated and raising her two daughters, Brittany and Ashley Gibson. On August 7, 1993, Todd and Linda got married. Their relationship got stronger.
They grew their family by having two sons, Trenton and Trevor, together. Todd also welcomed Linda’s nephew Cory into his home and raised him as if he were his own child. The Stermer family in Van Buren County, Michigan, looked like a close-knit and happy family.
But things were more complicated behind closed doors. Todd and Linda were having problems in their marriage, money problems, and accusations of cheating. These issues were worsening their relationship, ultimately leading to tragedy.
The Tragic Day: January 7, 2007
On the afternoon of January 7, 2007, Todd’s home in Lawrence caught fire. According to Linda, she had been doing laundry in the basement when she heard Todd scream. She said she rushed upstairs to find the living room in flames.
Linda claimed she ran outside without shoes or a phone and got into the family’s van to seek help. She said she saw Todd outside, badly burnt, and tried to convince him to get into the vehicle. When he refused, she attempted to drive the van on the muddy driveway but got stuck. She later drove around the house toward a sandy patch for traction.
CBS News reports that neighbours Mike Matheny and Connie Calhoun rushed to the scene and found Todd lying on the ground, badly burnt and barely conscious. Mike covered him with his clothes while they waited for emergency responders. Despite efforts by paramedics, Todd succumbed to smoke inhalation and thermal injuries shortly after. He was just 42 years old.
Fire investigators determined the blaze started in the living room. A gasoline can was found in the front yard and Todd’s clothing tested positive for gasoline residue. His injuries also included rib fractures and head lacerations, raising questions about what really happened that day.
Investigation Findings and Evidence
It didn’t take long for the investigation to point to Linda. A few pieces of evidence made people suspicious:
- Gasoline Residue: Todd’s underwear, socks, and sweatpants all tested positive for gasoline.
- Vehicle Evidence: Blood was found on the van’s bumper and undercarriage, which suggests that Todd may have been hit by a car.
- Marital Tensions: Witnesses said that Todd and Linda had fought about money and cheating the night before the fire.
- Gas Station Witness: A clerk said that on the morning of the fire, Linda was seen filling a container with gas at a nearby station. This matched the can found at the property.
Later, Todd’s sons Trenton and Trevor said that their parents had a big fight the day before he died. Ashley, Linda’s daughter, on the other hand, said that Todd was controlling and abusive.
The police decided that Todd’s death was not an accident. They thought Linda started the fire on purpose and then ran over her husband when he tried to get away.
Timeline of Events / Investigation
Here’s a simplified timeline of how things happened in the case to help you understand it better:
- On January 6, 2007, Todd and Linda are said to have fought about money and cheating.
- January 7, 2007 (Morning): Linda was seen at a petrol station, possibly filling up a petrol can.
- On January 7, 2007 (Afternoon): A fire broke out at the Stermer house. Neighbours found Todd outside with serious burns.
- January 7, 2007 (Later): Todd succumbed to his injuries. Evidence of gasoline and blood linked Linda to the incident.
- June 5, 2009: Linda Stermer arrested and charged with first-degree murder and arson.
- January 2010: Trial began; Linda convicted of murder and sentenced to life without parole.
- 2016–2018: Federal court granted Linda a new hearing due to prosecutorial misconduct and ineffective counsel.
- 2018: Conviction overturned; Linda released after nearly nine years in prison.
- 2021–2025: Retrial delayed multiple times; eventually began in March 2025.
- May 19, 2025: Jury found Linda guilty again; she was sentenced to life without parole.
The Trial and Conviction
During Linda’s first trial in 2010, the prosecutors said she started the fire on purpose, hit Todd, and then ran him over. Evidence of marital problems, debt, and her supposed affair added to the motive.
Witnesses’ testimony made her defence even weaker. Kate Fox, a co-worker, said that Linda once said she was afraid investigators would find the cup that she used to drug Todd with coffee.
The court concluded that Todd’s injuries — rib fractures and head lacerations — suggested he was assaulted before the fire. Combined with the gasoline residue and vehicle evidence, the jury found Linda guilty of first-degree premeditated murder and felony murder during arson. She was sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Appeals and Overturned Conviction
Linda kept fighting her conviction. She went to federal court in 2016 and said her trial was unfair.
In 2018, a federal judge ruled in her favour, saying that the prosecution had made mistakes and that there weren’t enough qualified fire experts. After almost nine years in prison, her conviction was overturned and she was set free.
For a short time, it looked like Linda might stay free. But Michigan’s Attorney General appealed the decision, and after years of legal delays, a new trial was set.
Where is Linda Stermer now?
In March 2025, the retrial finally started. Once again, prosecutors showed the evidence that linked Linda to Todd’s death, and this time, a new jury came to the same conclusion as the first one.
Linda Stermer was found guilty of first-degree premeditated murder and first-degree felony murder on May 19, 2025. She was given a life sentence with no chance of parole.
Linda is still in prison in Michigan, where she is serving her life sentence as of 2025. People in the legal community are still talking about her case as an example of how retrials can bring new attention to complicated evidence and the behaviour of prosecutors.
You can always count on Spiky TV to give you clear and reliable information about true crime stories and detailed case breakdowns.
Read More: Helen Huff Murder: How Phillip Sifuentes’ Violent Past Led to Tragedy
