Reality TV often brings couples together in ways that fans don’t expect. For example, Colt Johnson and Cortney Reardanz from season 1 of TLC’s 90 Day: Hunt for Love surprised fans more than any other couple. They were unsure about their time on the show, but it soon became one of the season’s most talked-about romances. Viewers of Spiky TV were curious about the couple’s relationship and whether it would last off-screen.
In this article, we’ll look back at how their relationship developed on the show, the problems they had, and what their lives are like now.
Who Are Colt Johnson and Cortney Reardanz?
Colt and Cortney are well-known to fans of 90 Day Fiancé. They are both going to the romantic retreat in Tulum, Mexico, with their own stories.
Colt Johnson: Colt first appeared in Season 6 of 90 Day Fiancé in 2018 with his then-fiancée Larissa Dos Santos Lima. He is a veteran of the 90 Day universe. Their messy divorce, which was made worse by drama with Colt’s mum, Debbie, made the news. Later, he married Vanessa Guerra, but their marriage ended after an accident on a trampoline put a strain on their relationship. At the time Hunt for Love was filmed in October 2024, Colt was single, getting over his divorce, and ready for a new beginning. He has been in 11 franchise shows and is known for being a “mama’s boy,” which makes him a controversial but well-liked person.
Cortney Reardanz: Cortney made her first appearance in 2017 on 90 Day Fiancé: Before the 90 Days Season 1, where she talked about her failed relationship with Spanish actor Antonio Millón. She is a real estate agent in Florida and has also been on spin-offs like Self-Quarantined and 90 Day Diaries. Cortney joined Hunt for Love because she was having trouble with online dating and wanted to find a real connection. She stood out on the show because she was bubbly and kept her heart safe.
The premise of 90 Day: Hunt for Love brought these two together with other franchise singles, like Usman “Sojaboy” Umar and Tiffany Franco, for therapy, group dates, and a chance to spark new romances. Little did fans expect Colt and Cortney to become the season’s breakout couple.
How Colt and Cortney’s Romance Began
The story began at the show’s masquerade ball, where all the singles met for the first time. Things didn’t get hot right away. Cortney, who had seen Colt’s past arguments with exes and his mom, told him straight out, “I’m not going to like you.” She thought he was “trouble” and didn’t like what she heard about him. Colt, on the other hand, was drawn to her honesty and kept finding ways to connect with her during group activities like breakfast chats and speed-dating events.
As the season went on, their relationships got stronger. They became close because they both had to deal with heartbreak and the stress of being on reality TV. But things got complicated when Usman Umar, another 90 Day alum known for his charm and music career, also showed interest in Cortney. Usman went after Cortney hard, calling her “my girl” and telling Colt to stay away. This made for a juicy love triangle that kept people watching. Cortney said she was torn between Usman’s attention, which was flattering and Colt’s quieter approach, which was starting to win her over.
View this post on Instagram
The Injury That Changed Everything
The turning point came in Episode 8, aired on July 21, 2025. Colt suffered a severe leg injury after slipping on a wet deck outside Cortney’s room at the resort. The fall, which aggravated a prior injury related to his marriage to Vanessa, was excruciating. Colt needed emergency surgery and was moved between hospitals in Tulum and Playa del Carmen. Cortney, who was about to go on a date with Usman when the accident happened, stayed by Colt’s side. In a surprising move, she even told hospital staff she was his wife to ensure she could stay with him.
This was a turning point in the game. Cortney’s help during Colt’s weak time made their relationship stronger. She spent hours with him, comforting him and talking to the doctors, even skipped filming to stay the night. Colt later said this experience took their relationship “to a whole other level.” Cortney agreed, admitting she felt closer to him in the hospital than she had at the resort. Fans saw a softer side of both, and their connection seemed genuine.
Choosing Each Other in the Finale
By the finale, aired on August 19, 2025, Cortney had made her choice clear. Despite Usman’s efforts, she picked Colt, cutting ties with Usman, who graciously stepped back. Cortney’s commitment went further—she called her parents to ask if Colt, who was reportedly without a stable home at the time, could stay with them in Orlando during his recovery. They agreed, and Colt moved in, signalling that they were serious about giving their relationship a real shot. Cortney openly shared her feelings, saying she wanted to build something lasting with Colt.
Cracks Revealed at the Tell All
The 90 Day: Hunt for Love Tell All, filmed in June 2025 and aired on August 25-26, gave fans a deeper look into their relationship. Hosted by Sukanya Krishnan, the reunion was full of surprises. Colt, still using a cane due to his injury, hinted at “surprises” but dodged questions about their status. Cortney opened up about challenges they faced after the show. She revealed that Colt had been talking to other women and planning meetups and one admirer even sent him flowers. His exes, including Larissa, stirred drama online, accusing him of using Cortney for a place to stay or health insurance.
Cortney admitted trust was a major issue, especially since they hadn’t said “I love you” until after leaving the retreat. She said, “We weren’t saying ‘I love you’ when he came to my house.” Despite this, Colt shared that he was still living with Cortney’s parents in Orlando, describing it as “definitely different.” They confirmed they’d expressed love for each other, but the cracks were evident. Cortney wondered if she’d made the “wrong decision,” while Colt seemed optimistic but vague about their future.
Are Colt and Cortney still together now?
The couple left the retreat as a pair, but their future has remained complicated. As of the Tell All taping, they were still living together and trying to work through their issues. Cortney admitted that while they weren’t saying “I love you” yet, they were making progress and taking things step by step.
On social media, fans have noticed subtle but significant indications that they remained in contact after the movie’s release. Cortney made fun of Colt’s Instagram posts, sometimes making fun of drama and even showed concern when he talked about his leg injury. Colt also posted pictures with Cortney in them, which showed that they were still close.
But reports from outside the show have made things seem less certain. Some people close to the situation said that Colt might have been asked to leave Cortney’s house, which makes people wonder if their living situation was more for show than for real life. This has led people to think that their relationship might not have lasted long after the show.
At the moment, their situation seems to be complicated. Fans are still guessing because there haven’t been any clear updates, even though there were signs of love and efforts to make things work. Their relationship is still up in the air until either Colt or Cortney says otherwise.
View this post on Instagram
Cortney Reardanz: Life After the Show
Cortney has made a name for herself as a realtor and a content creator outside of reality TV. She got a degree in finance from Eastern Illinois University and then worked for the Walt Disney Company for a few years before becoming an entrepreneur.
She first appeared on reality TV in 90 Day Fiancé: Before the 90 Days. Since then, she has been in several spin-offs, such as 90 Day Diaries and Self-Quarantined. She became a full-time real estate agent in 2022 and joined LPT Realty in Tampa. Since then, she has helped clients buy, sell, and invest in real estate.
Cortney has a strong online presence outside of real estate, with more than 130,000+ Instagram followers. She writes about travel, lifestyle, beauty, and food. She works with companies like Fabletics and promotes services like Dr. Phillips’ Serotonin Centre. She also makes money from exclusive content on sites like Unfiltrd and gives product recommendations on Amazon.
Cortney stays close to her family even though she has a lot going on. She often spends time with her niece, which shows how much she loves her family life in addition to her work.
View this post on Instagram
Colt Johnson: From Software Engineer to Digital Creator
Colt’s journey has also been captivating. He first showed up in season 6 of 90 Day Fiancé and then came back for other shows. Colt worked as a software development engineer at Konami Gaming before he got into reality TV. But he lost his job in 2020, which pushed him to make content.
He started his entertainment media company in 2021 and saw digital platforms as a new career path. Colt has more than 250,000+ followers on Instagram, where he talks about his life, promotes his Cameo services and interacts with fans.
A lot of his recent posts have been about how he’s recovering from a serious leg injury. He has kept his followers updated on his surgery and learning to walk again with crutches. His honesty about his problems has helped him keep a loyal fan base.
Colt is very close to his mother, Debbie, who has been on TV with him a lot. He has also talked about how sad he is that his father, Harley, died of a heart attack. His love for his cats is still a big part of his personal life, along with his family. This gives fans another look at his softer side.
Their journey is a reminder that not all reality TV romances are simple, but they do keep fans interested long after the cameras stop rolling. And for those who are interested, news about their relationship is still one of the most popular topics in the 90 Day Fiancé world, even on sites like Spiky TV.
Read More: 90 Day Fiancé: Are Wayne Cornish and Holly Weeks Still Together?
