The defence began calling witnesses today after a Massachusetts court denied a motion to dismiss charges against Michelle Carter, a 20-year-old accused with involuntary manslaughter for allegedly inciting her then-boyfriend to commit suicide. Conrad Roy, who was 18 at the time, died of carbon monoxide poisoning after locking himself in his truck in July 2014. Carter, then 17, is accused of being careless and causing his death by telling him to get back in the car even though he didn’t want to die, according to the prosecution. Carter, on the other hand, maintains her innocence.
‘The Girl from Plainville‘ is a series that tells the terrible story of Conrad Roy III’s death and Michelle Carter’s role in it. The Hulu mini-series chronicles the circumstances leading up to Michelle’s suicide and the court battles that followed. As a result, the show depicts a variety of complicated, often perplexing circumstances while remaining balanced in its quest to finding an answer for the tragedy.
Michelle’s trial begins in Episode 6, and a number of witnesses assist in piecing together the events. What is also clear is that the accused is anxious for the acceptance and company of people she considers to be her friends. We took a close look at Michelle Carter’s actual court hearings and compiled a list of all the important witnesses who testified.
Michelle Carter’s Trial: Who Were the Eyewitnesses?
Under the supervision of Judge Lawrence Moniz, the prosecution (headed by associate district attorney Katie Rayburn) and defence (counsel Joseph Cataldo) eventually came to an agreement on who was admissible and who wasn’t in Michelle Carter’s 2017 trial. Michelle was facing a charge of involuntary manslaughter, which could have resulted in a sentence of up to twenty years in prison.
Samantha Boardman and Lexie Eblan, Michelle’s former classmates, testified during the trial. The former, who appeared to be Michelle’s former best friend (based on her text messages), seemed to be closer to Lexie than the latter. The two were at Michelle’s house for a sleepover the week before Conrad Roy’s suicide, but they didn’t appear to remember anything about their time there.
Dr. Peter Breggin, who has provided expert testimony on psychopharmacology in the past, was one of the primary witnesses produced by the defence. Michelle had involuntary intoxication, according to the doctor, as a result of the effects of Celexa, an antidepressant that impacted her character. Steven Verraneau, an electronics forensics expert, took the stand and detailed his findings based on data taken from Michelle and Conrad’s phones and computers.
A number of law enforcement authorities, including Massachusetts State Police Trooper Michael Bates, testified as witnesses. The official claimed to have found Michelle’s text messages on Conrad’s phone and read out some of their conversations. The defence also called two Mattapoisett cops to testify about an incident in which Conrad was assaulted by his father. During the judicial processes, however, the 2013 assault and battery episode was not explored in full.
Michelle and Conrad’s communications were essential in the incident, which has become known as the “texting-suicide” case. Olivia Mosologo, a friend of Michelle’s, read aloud a shocking and heartbreaking message delivered after Conrad’s death.
Samantha Boardman also read out one of Michelle’s most well-known text messages, which she sent roughly two months after Conrad died. “I could have stopped him,” the message said, “but I told him to get back in the car.”
Was Conrad’s Father A Witness for the Defense?
Lynne Roy and Conrad H. Roy, Jr., both of Conrad’s parents, testified during Michell’s trial. Among other things, the former mentioned contacting the authorities if her son did not return home the night before he died. Michelle also sent her a series of text messages after her son died, providing encouragement and expressing her love for Conrad, she said.
Although the defence was not allowed to go into depth about domestic violence reports in the Roy family, Conrad’s father testified. He wasn’t a defence witness, and when Joseph Cataldo tried to ask about an alleged fight between Conrad and his father, the judge put an end to the defense’s line of questioning.