What Did Pastor Jack Schaap Do? Where is He Now?

Pastor Jack Schaap – Hey there, curious minds! Today, we’re diving into the twists and turns of a scandal that rocked the Independent Fundamentalist Baptist community, featuring none other than Pastor Jack Schaap. If you caught the riveting episode on Investigation Discovery’s ‘Let Us Prey: A Ministry of Scandals,’ you’re in for a wild ride. This eye-opening show sheds light on the dark side of the Independent Fundamentalist Baptist (IFB) world, revealing shocking criminal acts committed against those under their power. Now, let’s unravel the enigma of Pastor Jack Schaap and explore where he stands today.

Who is Jack Schaap?

Let’s set the stage by getting to know the man himself. Jack Schaap, not your average pastor, was deeply embedded in the IFB hierarchy. His journey in the Independent Fundamentalist Baptist world began in his formative years, as he pursued education under the organization’s guidance. Schaap’s academic endeavors led him to Hyles-Anderson College, where he earned not one, not two, but three degrees. Talk about dedication! From a bachelor’s in Christian Theology to a master’s in Pastoral Theology and finally a doctorate in Pastoral Ministry, Schaap was climbing the ecclesiastical ladder.

Marriage brought him into the inner sanctum of the IFB, tying the knot with Cindy Hyles, the daughter of Jack Hyles, the Senior Pastor of First Baptist Church of Hammond, until his passing in 2001. Schaap stepped into the spotlight, taking over as Senior Pastor for the First Baptist Church of Hammond and simultaneously assuming the role of Chancellor at Hyles-Anderson College, his alma mater. His influence in the IFB hierarchy was palpable as he ushered in new members and left an indelible mark on the church.

What Did Pastor Jack Schaap Do?

The bombshell dropped in the summer of 2012, shaking the foundations of the First Baptist Church of Hammond, Indiana. Picture this: a revered pastor, a man of influence within the IFB hierarchy, abruptly ousted from his position. The reason? Brace yourself – Jack Schaap had engaged in sexual relations with a 16-year-old girl, a student at the church’s high school.

Now, let’s dissect the shocking revelation. While Indiana’s age of consent allowed Schaap to sidestep the legal definition of rape, the circumstances surrounding the encounters were nothing short of disturbing. The church, citing adultery, swiftly dismissed him from his pastoral and chancellery roles, revealing a sordid tale of manipulation and exploitation.

Schaap had allegedly orchestrated these encounters under the guise of “counseling sessions.” The veil of trust meant to provide solace and guidance, became a tool for his sinister actions. The young girl, older than the legal age of consent, was allegedly lured into a web of deception, with Schaap painting his actions as sanctioned by a higher power.

During the investigation, prosecutors laid bare the extent of Schaap’s predatory behavior. Picture this: he referred to the girl as “extremely vulnerable” and facilitated their encounters by crossing state lines to Illinois and Michigan. Why? To conduct “counseling” sessions without raising eyebrows. Disturbing, right?

But it doesn’t stop there. Schaap’s manipulation went beyond physical encounters. Love letters, disguised as spiritual guidance, were used to groom the young girl. In one letter, he wrote, “In our ‘fantasy talk,’ you have affectionately spoken of being ‘my wife.’ That is exactly what Christ desires for us.” These letters painted a distorted picture of a relationship sanctioned by a higher calling.

As the legal proceedings unfolded, Schaap attempted to deflect blame, citing his prostate, exhaustion from long work weeks, and financial strain as contributing factors. Prosecutors, however, dismissed these excuses, stating that his excessive work hours were likely dedicated to grooming and sexually abusing the victim.

The sentencing in 2013 saw Schaap plead guilty to transporting his victim across state lines for the purpose of sexual exploitation. A 12-year prison sentence became the consequence of his actions, with the judge taking into account the grotesque nature of the offense and the immense impact on the victim’s life.

As we navigate through the layers of this scandal, it becomes clear that the repercussions extend far beyond a pastor’s fall from grace. The story of Jack Schaap serves as a stark reminder of the vulnerable positions individuals can find themselves in within tightly-knit religious communities and the importance of safeguarding trust and accountability.

Where is Ex-Pastor Jack Schaap Now?

Now, let’s zoom into the present chapter of Jack Schaap’s life – a chapter shrouded in mystery since his early release on May 4, 2022. Picture this: the once prominent IFB figure, now a free man, navigating the complexities of post-prison existence.

Before the doors swung open, Schaap hinted at having no family in Indiana, with his parents residing in Michigan. The lack of transparency surrounding his early release stirred quite the commotion among those fervently advocating for justice within the IFB community.

Schaap remained tight-lipped about his plans and whereabouts as he re-entered the world beyond prison walls. The man who once held a position of trust and influence within the IFB hierarchy seemed to vanish into thin air, leaving many wondering about his next moves.

Schaap Pleads for Compassionate Release: A Glimpse into His Current Struggle

Fast forward to a more recent development. Schaap made a heartfelt plea for compassionate release in a handwritten letter to U.S. District Judge James T. Moody, dated January 23, 2023. Why, you ask? His elderly parents, aged 87 and 84, are grappling with failing health.

Let’s hear it in his own words: “My father had fallen several times, including Jan 23, injuring his left arm, shoulder, hip, and knee. He can’t use his left arm and is in deteriorating health. He is the sole caregiver for my invalid mother.”

Schaap painted a poignant picture of his parents’ struggles, emphasizing that they couldn’t afford a nursing home. In his plea, he stressed the urgency of the situation, stating, “At their age, and in their condition, days and weeks spell the difference between life and death.”

But, of course, there are two sides to every story. Acting U.S. Attorney Gary T. Bell opposed Schaap’s plea, deeming him a potential danger if released early. The opposition highlighted the delicate balance between Schaap’s desire for redemption and the potential risks associated with his freedom.

Amid this legal tug-of-war, Schaap reiterated his commitment to redemption, assuring the judge, “I can only give you my word that I will do my utmost to be a worthy citizen of society.” He underlined that while he aims for personal redemption, his immediate concern is the well-being of his ailing parents.

The First Baptist Church of Hammond’s Stand

In the aftermath of Schaap’s release and subsequent legal tussle, the First Baptist Church of Hammond took a stand, making it clear that they were aware of Schaap’s release but affirming that he would have no connection to the church or Hyles-Anderson College.

Rick Sparks, a spokesman for the church, issued a statement: “Our ministry has not had contact with him, and we do not know his future plans. We are confident he will not have any connection to First Baptist Church or Hyles-Anderson College.”

As the legal proceedings unfold and Schaap grapples with personal and legal challenges, the community watches with bated breath, pondering the intricate web of consequences stemming from his actions.

In the next installment of this unfolding saga, we’ll explore the judge’s decision regarding Schaap’s plea for compassionate release and delve deeper into the ongoing repercussions of a scandal that shook the foundations of the IFB community.

Must Read: Who is IFB Survivor Ruthy Heiler and Where is She Now?