Only Murders in the Building Season 2 Episode 5 “The Tell” Recap and Ending Explained – In episode five, Mabel throws an unconventional party in her bare apartment, and Oliver uses his unique skill set to rule out a potential suspect. Another exciting episode that moves us one step closer to identifying the identity of the elusive killer.
The trio orbits around a difficult suspect in the 5th episode of the season, titled “The Tell.” The research interferes with Mabel’s romantic life, and Oliver discovers a terrible secret about his background.
In the meantime, Charles reignites an old love in quest of solutions, but he soon finds himself reverting to old habits. Here is everything you need to know about the conclusion of season 2 of “Only Murders in the Building“ if you are attempting to make sense of the episode’s convoluted and jumbled events!
Only Murders in the Building Season 2 Episode 5 “The Tell” Recap
The opening scene of the fifth episode, “The Tell,” takes place in the 1970s, when Young Oliver is shown playing the party game “Son of Sam.” Thanks to the game, Oliver gains a knack for figuring out whether someone is concealing something. Another flashback that takes place during Will, Oliver’s son’s early years, demonstrates how Oliver has honed his ability to recognize people’s “tell” over time. Charles encounters Jan Bellows in the present and requests her assistance in identifying Bunny’s killer.
Jan hypothesizes that the murderer must be a storyteller or artist of some kind because they constructed the crime scene to place Charles, Mabel, and Oliver under suspicion. Charles is tasked by Jan to determine whether any artists have entered the group’s lives as a result of the tragedy.
Alice explains that she needs a location to have a party because her flat is flooded. To host the gathering at her house, Mabel consents. In the meantime, Mabel looks for hints in the hidden corridor and discovers a matchbox from the Pickle Diner. Mabel shows Oliver and Charles the matchbox from the hallway. She also shares the two details of Alice’s celebration at her residence.
As a result, Charles and Oliver begin to believe Alice is responsible for Bunny’s death. Oliver later observes Ivan leave a money envelope on Bunny’s door. He inquires about his relationship with Bunny with the server. Ivan presents Oliver with CCTV footage from the day before Bunny died while denying any role in the homicide.
The video shows that Bunny encountered an enigmatic character at the diner. Bunny became agitated by the customer and rushed out of the establishment. Oliver, however, is unable to determine the person’s identity because the video is too blurry. Oliver does see the person picking up a matchbox that matches the one Mabel found in the hallway.
Oliver starts a Son of Sam game during the party to get Alice to reveal her true motives for wanting to be close to Mabel. Oliver’s strategy fails, though, because his attack on Alice simply makes clear that Alice’s poor childhood was the cause of her lies.
Only Murders in the Building Season 2 Episode 5 Ending Explained
After Oliver reveals Alice’s past, Mabel and Alice become more intimate, and their connection develops. In the meantime, Charles sees Jan again and starts to feel safe in her company despite their past. However, a significant revelation that connects the episode’s opening flashbacks and divulges a secret about Oliver’s background occurs in the last seconds of the show. Watchers are introduced to Will working on his son’s ancestry project for school in the first few minutes of the episode.
Will returns with the ancestry test results at the end of the episode. Will reveals that his mother’s side of the family is where his ethnicity should be.
Oliver claims to be Irish, which raises questions about Will’s ancestry. But the test shows that Will is Greek on his father’s side. As a result, he asks Oliver whether he is certain of his Irish ancestry. The revelation transports Oliver back to the evening of the party that viewers see in a flashback at the beginning of the episode. In a game of Son of Sam during the party, Oliver correctly deduces that Teddy Dimas is the murderer.
As the memory continues, Oliver makes a lighthearted remark about if Teddy is keeping a new secret. Oliver is seated between Teddy and his wife, Roberta, in the final awkward scene. Teddy and Roberta may have been having an affair behind Oliver’s back, according to the scene.
As a result, Will might be Teddy’s child, which would account for his Greek heritage. Despite the possibility that Will is Teddy’s child, it is more likely that Teddy faked the ancestry test as part of his scheme to end Oliver’s life. The episode ends without addressing the reality of the matter because Oliver is unaware of this revelation.
— 🔊 ANGEL IN FLIP FLOPS #1 ON THE CHARTS 👼🩴 (@OnlyMurdersHulu) July 19, 2022